User-oriented Assessment of Classification Model Understandability
Hiva Allahyari, Niklas Lavesson · Frontiers in artificial intelligence and applications · 2011
This paper reviews methods for evaluating and analyzing the understandability of classification models in the context of data mining. The motivation for this study is the fact that the majority of previous work on evaluation and optimization of classification models has focused on assessing or increasing the accuracy of the models and thus user-oriented properties such as comprehensibility and understandability have been largely overlooked. We conduct a quantitative survey to examine the concept of understandability from the user's point of view. The survey results are analyzed using the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) to rank models according to their understandability. The results indicate that decision tree models are perceived as more understandable than rule-based models. Using the survey results regarding understandability of a number of models in conjunction with quantitative measurements of the complexity of the models, we are able to establish a negative correlation between the complexity and understandability of the classification models, at least for one of the two studied data sets.