RMComBat: A Batch Effect Correction Algorithm for Repeated Measurement Sequencing Data to Prevent Overcorrection
Yuqian Liu, Zhenfang Wei, Jiayin Wang, Xiaoyan Zhu, Ruoyu Liu, Xuwen Wang, Shenjie Wang, Xin Lai · 2024
Batch effects, caused by non-biological variations such as differences in laboratory conditions, reagent lots, or personnel, are a substantial source of noise in gene expression data. Accurately correcting these effects is crucial for valid biological inferences. However, the majority of existing batch effect correction algorithms are prone to overcorrection, where biologically meaningful signals are mistakenly identified as noise, especially in repeated measurement studies where time is confounded with batch. The failure to accurately distinguish between batch-related and biologically relevant variation leads to a loss of critical biological information. This paper presents RMComBat, an enhancement of the widely-used ComBat framework, which addresses this limitation by replacing the general linear model with a linear mixed-effects model. RMComBat incorporates subject-specific random intercepts to correct for sample correlation and enhance the preservation of biological signals. We tested RMComBat and several popular algorithms on simulated and real repeated measurement gene expression datasets, evaluating their performance through visual inspections and quantitative metrics. Results indicate that although most algorithms can reduce batch effects, they often do so at the cost of removing true biological signals. RMComBat demonstrates superior performance in preventing overcorrection, providing a more balanced and biologically informative correction in repeated measurement studies, so making it a valuable tool for improving the accuracy of gene expression analyses.