Analyzing Bias in Large Language Model Solutions for Assisted Writing Feedback Tools: Lessons from the Feedback Prize Competition Series
Perpetual Baffour, Tor Saxberg, Scott A. Crossley · 2023
This paper analyzes winning solutions from the Feedback Prize competition series hosted from 2021-2022.The competitions sought to improve Assisted Writing Feedback Tools (AWFTs) by crowdsourcing Large Language Model (LLM) solutions for evaluating student writing.The winning LLM-based solutions are freely available for incorporation into educational applications, but the models need to be assessed for performance and other factors.This study reports the performance accuracy of Feedback Prizewinning models based on demographic factors such as student race/ethnicity, economic disadvantage, and English Language Learner status.Two competitions are analyzed.The first, which focused on identifying discourse elements, demonstrated minimal bias based on students' demographic factors.However, the second competition, which aimed to predict discourse effectiveness, exhibited moderate bias.