Van Inwagen’s Approach to Relations and the Theory of O-Roles
Francesco Orilia · 2019
In “Names for Relations,” Van Inwagen presents a semantic problem about names for non-symmetric relations, based on the presupposition that there are converse relations. This paper first provides an analysis of Van Inwagen’s problem and then addresses it by appealing to o-roles such as ‘agent,’ ‘patient,’ ‘theme,’ instrument, etc., and by distinguishing sparse and abundant levels of properties and relations. At the sparse level, o-roles are appealed to in order to tackle the problem of relational order and reject converse relations. At the abundant level, converse relations are recovered in the light of the sequential character of thinking, speaking and writing, and Van Inwagen problem is solved by giving due consideration to the order in which relata are assigned o-roles and referred to.