Using a Three-step Social Media Similarity (TSMS) Mapping Method to Analyze Controversial Speech Relating to COVID-19 in Twitter Collections
Zhanyuan Yin, Lizhou Fan, Huizi Yu, Anne J. Gilliland · 2020
Addressing increasing calls to surface hidden and counter-narratives from within archival collections, this paper reports on a study that provides proof-of-concept of automatic methods that could be used on archived social media collections. Using a test collection of 3,457,434 unique tweets relating to COVID-19, China and Chinese people, it sought to identify instances of Hate Speech as well as hard-to-pinpoint trends in anti-Chinese racist sentiment. The study, part of a larger archival research effort investigating automatic methods for appraisal and description of very large digital archival collections, used a Three-step Social Media Similarity (TSMS) mapping method that aggregates hashtag mapping, TF-IDF Similarity Selection, and Emotion Similarity Calculation on the test collection. Compared to using a purely lexicon-based method to identify and analyze controversial speech, this method successfully expanded the amount of controversial contents detected from 21,050 tweets to 212,605, and the detection rate from 0.6% to 6.1%. We argue that the TSMS method could be similarly applied by archives in automatically identifying, analyzing, describing other controversial content on social media and in other rapidly evolving and complex contexts in order to increase public awareness and facilitate public policy responses.