Comment on four two-party authentication protocols.
Yalin Chen, Jue‐Sam Chou, Chun-Hui Huang · 2010
In this paper, we analyze the protocols of Bindu et al., Goriparthi et al., Wang et al. and Hölbl et al.. After analyses, we found that Bindu et al.’s protocol suffers from the insider attack if the smart card is lost, both Goriparthi et al.’s and Wang et al.’s protocols can’t withstand the DoS attack on the password change phase which makes the password invalid after the protocol run, and Hölbl et al.’s protocol is vulnerable to the insider attack since a malevolent legal user can deduce KGC’s secret key xs.