Identifying Missing and Extra Notes in Piano Recordings Using Score-Informed Dictionary Learning
Siying Wang, Sebastian Ewert, Simon Dixon · IEEE/ACM Transactions on Audio Speech and Language Processing · 2017
The goal of automatic music transcription (AMT) is to obtain a high-level symbolic representation of the notes played in a given audio recording. Despite being researched for several decades, current methods are still inadequate for many applications. To boost the accuracy in a music tutoring scenario, we exploit that the score to be played is specified and we only need to detect the differences to the actual performance. In contrast to previous work that uses score information for postprocessing, we employ the score to construct a transcription method that is tailored to the given audio recording. By adapting a score-informed dictionary learning technique as used for source separation, we learn for each score pitch a spectral pattern describing the energy distribution of associated notes in the recording. In this paper, we identify several systematic weaknesses in our previous approach and introduce three extensions to improve its performance. First, we extend our dictionary of spectral templates to a dictionary of variable-length spectrotemporal patterns. Second, we integrate the score information using soft rather than hard constraints, to better take into account that differences from the score indeed occur. Third, we introduce new regularizers to guide the learning process. Our experiments show that these extensions particularly improve the accuracy for identifying extra notes, while the accuracy for correct and missing notes remains at a similar level. The influence of each extension is demonstrated with further experiments.