From the experts' review opinions to the editorial comments
Shao Kai-yun · Bianji xuebao · 2011
In an academic journal,the experts' opinion is an important component of the editorial comment and is an authoritative reference.But they are not the same and cannot simply be transferred.The editor,from the perspective of the journal and the author,shall base on the principle of how it works to carefully convert the experts' opinion to the editorial comment.That is,by using an add or remove methodology upon a single expert's opinion as well as the comments from the editorial staff,the editor adjusts and compiles multiple experts' opinions to an overall balance,in compliance with the editorial standard.