Complexity effective memory access scheduling for many-core accelerator architectures
George L. Yuan, Ali Bakhoda, Tor M. Aamodt · 2009
Modern DRAM systems rely on memory controllers that employ out-of-order scheduling to maximize row access lo-cality and bank-level parallelism, which in turn maximizes DRAM bandwidth. This is especially important in graphics processing unit (GPU) architectures, where the large quan-tity of parallelism places a heavy demand on the memory system. The logic needed for out-of-order scheduling can be expensive in terms of area, especially when compared to an in-order scheduling approach. In this paper, we propose a complexity-effective solution to DRAM request schedul-ing which recovers most of the performance loss incurred by a naive in-order first-in first-out (FIFO) DRAM scheduler compared to an aggressive out-of-order DRAM scheduler. We observe that the memory request stream from individual GPU“shader cores ” tends to have sufficient row access local-ity to maximize DRAM efficiency in most applications with-out significant reordering. However, the interconnection net-work across which memory requests are sent from the shader cores to the DRAM controller tends to finely interleave the numerous memory request streams in a way that destroys the row access locality of the resultant stream seen at the DRAM controller. To address this, we employ an intercon-nection network arbitration scheme that preserves the row access locality of individual memory request streams and, in doing so, achieves DRAM efficiency and system perfor-mance close to that achievable by using out-of-order mem-ory request scheduling while doing so with a simpler de-sign. We evaluate our interconnection network arbitration scheme using crossbar, mesh, and ring networks for a base-line architecture of 8 memory channels, each controlled by its own DRAM controller and 28 shader cores (224 ALUs), supporting up to 1,792 in-flight memory requests. Our re-sults show that our interconnect arbitration scheme coupled with a banked FIFO in-order scheduler obtains up to 91% of the performance obtainable with an out-of-order memory scheduler for a crossbar network with eight-entry DRAM controller queues.