Requirements of a good analytical chemistry research paper
Josephine M. Petruzzi · Journal of the American Oil Chemists Society · 1977
Abstract A good analytical chemistry research paper may be defined as one that passes the critical review of one’s peers for publication in a recognized reviewed jour‐nal. Factors to consider in publishing an analytical paper include careful selection of the right journal, clear concise presentation that emphasizes the re‐search contribution and its significance to the field, and careful revision if called for to account for the reviewers’ and editors’ criticisms. Rather special requirements apply to methods papers as opposed to other types of analytical papers. Data should be included to establish the accuracy and precision of the method by the use of standard reference mate‐rials, standard addition studies, interference studies, and comparisons with established methods. Day‐to‐day and run precision studies of the proposed method in a real setting help validate the method. Common problems with analytical papers are discussed. Specific suggestions are given for improving the likeli‐hood of publication. Data are given on the ultimate disposition of manuscripts submitted toAnalytical Chemistry. Reasons for rejection of papers submitted to the journal are summarized.