Comparison of Several Optimization Strategies for Robust Turbine Blade Design
Andy J. Keane · Journal of Propulsion and Power · 2009
This paper addresses the problem of turbine blade shape optimization in the presence of geometric uncertainties. Several strategies are tested and compared on a two-dimensional compressor blade optimization process for which performance is assessed using a commercial Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes computational fluid dynamics code. In each case, a range of shape errors are considered that attempt to simulate foreign object damage, erosion damage, and manufacturing errors. These lead to stochastic performance measures that, in turn, are considered in a multi-objective optimization framework. Because of the long run times associated with Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes codes, use is also made of surrogate or response surface-based optimization methods to speed up the search processes. The paper shows that a range of techniques can be used to tackle this problem, but that no one method is clearly best overall. The practitioner is therefore cautioned against favoring a single approach for such design problems. Further research may help clarify these issues