Comments on "Analysis of a hybrid multiple access protocol with free access of new arrivals during conflict resolution" [with reply]
Ahmed E. Kamal, Philippe Nain, N.D. Georganas, William J. Stewart · IEEE Transactions on Communications · 1990
The commenter points out an error made in the paper by P. Nain et al. (see ibid., vol.36, p.806-15, July 1988) and shows that correcting this error requires a state space that has an exponential size. The authors reply that the errors cannot easily be corrected and that their model provides a good approximation model for HYMAP.>