Robustness in complex systems
Steven D. Gribble · 2005
The paper argues that a common design paradigm for systems is fundamentally flawed, resulting in unstable, unpredictable behavior as the complexity of the system grows. In this flawed paradigm, designers carefully attempt to predict the operating environment and failure modes of the system in order to design its basic operational mechanisms. However, as a system grows in complexity, the diffuse coupling between the components in the system inevitably leads to the butterfly effect, in which small perturbations can result in large changes in behavior We explore this in the context of distributed data structures, a scalable, cluster-based storage server We then consider a number of design techniques that help a system to be robust in the face of the unexpected, including overprovisioning, admission control, introspection, adaptivity through closed control loops. Ultimately, however, all complex systems eventually must contend with the unpredictable. Because of this, we believe systems should be designed to cope with failure gracefully.