Is Parole Prediction a Science?
Ray L. Huff · Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (1931-1951) · 1936
When we find ourselves unable to agree with our friends, it seems to be appropriate that we confess and point out the path our thinking follows. Perhaps we can thereby be led to a point of mutual understanding from which more exact thinking may proceed. With this premise, I confess a lack of agreement with the recent article in the Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology written by William F. Lanne, which he titled Parole Prediction as Science. XXVI: 377. I use the statement of the Character Education Institute, Washington, D. C., to define the scientific method through which the constituent parts of a science are developed. Taking these steps seriatim, we should examine the studies in the field of parole prediction to determine their sufficiency as revealed by this measure. 1. Gather data on the problem within a selected field according to some adequate, sound plan by means of numerous and accurate observations made with the human senses assisted and corrected by instruments of precision. Observations must be recorded in definite terms and measurements and in specific statements.