Abductive interpretation and reinterpretation of natural language utterances
Susan McRoy · 1993
To decide how to respond to an utterance, a speaker must interpret what others have said and why they have said it. Speakers rely on their expectations to decide whether they have understood each other. Misunderstandings occur when speakers differ in their beliefs about what has been said or why. If a listener hears something that seems inconsistent, he may reinterpret an earlier utterance and respond to it anew. Otherwise, he assumes that the conversation is proceeding smoothly. Recognizing an inconsistency as a misunderstanding and generating a new reply together accomplish what is known as a fourth-position repair. To model the repair of misunderstandings, this thesis combines both intentional and social accounts of discourse, unifying theories of speech act production, interpretation, and repair. In intentional accounts, speakers use their beliefs, goals, and expectations to decide what to say; when they interpret an utterance, speakers identify goals that might account for it. In...